Thanks everyone for the advice! A friend had given us wooden “starter” paddles and we need to get rid of those ASAP. They weigh a lot and after playing for a while, it hurts both of our wrists.
We decided to try these as our next paddles. They aren’t super high end, but get good reviews. We didn’t want to invest in the higher end paddles until we make sure we like the sport and intend to continue playing regularly.
https://www.pickleballcentral.com/VERSIX_Strike_4F_Composite_Pickleball_Paddle_p/pbc705.htm
It seems really fun so far and shockingly, playing hasn’t bothered my hip injury yet. Right now I’m mainly doing drills (serving, dinking) and simple volleying, so when we get into more competitive playing, that may tax my hip differently. But so far, so good and we are having a lot of fun.