Common sense is not that abundant in the general population. While the basic LBYM and save & invest message is the admirable and long term beneficial thing accomplished, and I don’t begrudge anyone making a living by getting indirectly paid by advertisers for dispensing that advice, as has been mentioned many times here, MMM & FS both present themselves as “anyMan, that can do this” and both are patently misrepresenting themselves for that profit.
I am certainly not a FIRE snob, nor am I gloating at my relative success. But many years ago, when I first heard of FIRE, I did read both of them for a few days. Even back then, long before the latest reveals, it was SO obvious that much of what they said was unrealistic for the majority of common people, and the objective was obviously to increase clicks and yet they had hordes of followers fawning over their teachings as gospel. That is what bothered me most. How many people were duped in to unrealistic expectations and are now paying the price with no job, no income and no HI? Not that I can prove it, but I feel that they prey on people looking for an easy way to not work, and exploit that vulnerability by reinforcing that “anyone can do this” attitude when that is simply absolutely not true.
It takes a certain mindset, confidence, ability and other characteristics to FIRE young successfully. I did not have them, until I was already FI, which was always my plan, but through a long career that carried a pension and decently high salary based on a specialty that I chose specifically for its long term STEM desirability.
It’s not exclusivity to be realistic. Literally everything that can make one FI can be found free in this forum alone. How many posters here would contribute all or most of their FIRE success from primarily reading this forum? Not me, and I am relatively intelligent and level headed.