Katsmeow
Give me a museum and I'll fill it. (Picasso) Give me a forum ...
- Joined
- Jul 11, 2009
- Messages
- 5,308
DW is facing cataract surgery in both eyes. I have not yet gotten all the details of the options (she just received them today and is still nervous about the choices). From what she has told me, she has two surgery options: (a) eliminate the need for glasses or contacts, except for reading, or (b) eliminate the need for reading glasses but require glasses for everything else.
Currently she is very nearsighted. She can read books or work on a tablet without glasses, but for everything else she needs glasses. She reads a lot (one reason we have 5000+ books in our home ), and one concern she has is having to now use reading glasses. She is used to wearing glasses to get around.
OK...this is opinion. I think choice of cataract surgeon is really important. Cataract surgeons are not all alike. Some cataract surgeons tend to use certain brands of lenses and don't offer other brands. Some may not have the equipment needed for particular lenses. For example, the Light Adjustable Lens requires that the doctor have the equipment needed to adjust the power after surgery.
When I was thinking about cataract surgery, I knew I was interested in the Light Adjustable Lens and went to the manufacturer's website and found out who could do the surgery. As it turns out one of the doctors was the doctor who did my LASIK surgery years ago.
Another factor for me is looking at doctors who have been involved in clinical trials for various lenses. My thought was that the doctor who was involved in clinical trials might have more experience than someone who just started to use the lens.
Based upon what others have said on some other forums (more related to health) have said, many doctors don't really adequately explains options to patients. Sometimes people are not really told about options other than standard monofocal lenses or maybe are only told about the lens options that surgeon offers when there might be other options from other surgeons.
Unless your wife knows a lot about this surgeon and has a lot of confidence this is one of those things where getting more than one opinion makes sense (maybe even if she does have a lot of confidence).
From what you said it sounds like the surgeon offered your wife only one type of lens.
It sounds like they offered her only a monofocal lens choice. It sounds like they offered her only the choice of setting the focus for distance (she would wear glasses for reading and probably for intermediate distance such as computer or dashboard) OR setting the focus for near (she would not need glasses to read but would need it for everything else).
That sounds extremely limited. To be clear, some people really need a monofocal lens and can't really use the multifocal lenses or extended depth of focus lenses. For example, in my left eye I had a peel of a macular pucker and a vitrectomy and I need a monofocal lens for that eye. In my right eye, I am not a candidate for multifocal since I had LASIK but I could do the Vivity EDOF lens.
So, your wife may have some sort of eye condition that requires a monofocal lens.
However, even so there are options:
1. She could set one eye for distance and set the other eye for monovision, mini-monovision or micro-monovision. She could see more near with monovision rather than micro but true monovision may be harder to adjust to. It is possible the doctor didn't suggest that because your wife has previously tried monovision and didn't like it or doesn't want to try it now.
2. If you wife needs a monofocal lens, why not try a Light Adjustable Lens. That is a monofocal lens but you can adjust the power post surgery to set each eye exactly as you want. There are some great videos on You Tube about this lens.
The only negatives of the Light Adjustable lens are (1) it costs money and (2) you have to go through the adjustment process. To me, it was worth it to get the adjustment period afterwards. The other downside of this lens is that not all doctors can do it. But, that is solved by finding one who can.
3. Maybe your wife doesn't have any retinal or other eye problems that require a monofocal lens. If so, she might be a candidate for the PanOptix multifocal lens which can give good vision at all distances or a candidate for the Vivity lens which is giving me great distance vision, good intermediate, and what they call functional near vision (I can read my phone without glasses but I don't want to). There are other brands of premium lenses also (those two I mention are made by Alcon).
Maybe your wife does not want to get one of those lenses. That is fine. Everything is a trade off. But, if she is eligible for those lenses, why didn't the doctor discuss them? Again, maybe your wife isn't eligible or she wasn't interested in them.
I mention this simply because I sometimes have seen people have cataract surgery without really considering their options and the trade offs.