Peak Oil

How will peak oil affect us?

  • None

    Votes: 2 6.3%
  • Some

    Votes: 5 15.6%
  • Moderate

    Votes: 9 28.1%
  • Severe

    Votes: 14 43.8%
  • Saudi princes will be forced to take real jobs

    Votes: 2 6.3%

  • Total voters
    32
Bruce said:
Many Historical Economist consider the increase in whale oil cost and the shortages of whale oil as the first true energy crisis. At the time almost all interior lighting in the world was whale oil (sperm whale) based; there were no economical alternatives at the time. This whale oil burned cleanly and brightly and did not have a disagreeable odor.

Once the shortage and high prices of whale oil began, some enterprising company started producing Kerosene from COAL (yes you can produce a liquid fuel from a solid). Kerosene started to replace whale oil for interior lighting.

Other companies produced gas from coal (many of the older cities in the United States had a "Gas Works"conversion factory.

After Kerosene and coal gas started to be used, a major oil find in Pennsylvania in 1859 started the United States petroleum age. It because more economical to produce kerosene from oil then from coal so its use increased.

While I do not disagree with Hubbert and his bell curve of oil production, he does not take into account productivity improvements in extraction of oil; I think if these was put into his bell curve it would skew it to the left:

One of the first techniques that oil companies started using to increase the amount of oil that can be extracted from the ground were hydraulic fracturing and water flooding to drive more oil from the ground. Some other methods include CO2 injection, horizontal drilling, better computer 3 dimensional visualization technology. Maybe in the near future bacteria that will seperate oil from rocks will  be injected down oil wells increasing the supplies evern more.

Those who forget history are doomed to repeat it!

In my arrogant opinion, oil may not continue to increase in price until all the oil in the world is used; it worries me greatly when I hear some people say that "Its different this time".


  • The longer the price of energy (oil, natural gas, etc) stay high, the more exploration that will take place, increasing the supply.

    The longer the price of energy stay high, the more alternative energy supplies will become economically viable.

    The longer the price of energy stays high, the more people will begin to use less (the short term prices of energy are inelastic but longer term they become more elastic).

    The longer the price of energy stays high, the less economic growth that there will be;

    The longer the price of energy stays high, the greater the price of energy will fall; I would not want be an energy investor when this happens.


So before I would put too much money in energy stocks, I would look at the performance of energy stocks in the 1980's after a period of extended high prices during the 1970's.

Can anyone answer this question: How much of the price of oil being driven higher by speculation? Do some research; why is the price of finding a barrel of oil in the ground not rising as fast as the price of oil?

An aside to the energy crisis and new technology; LED lights are about to become a mainstream fixture in American Homes. These lights are already being used in traffic lights throughout the country; for every bulb replaced $75.00 dollars in electricity is saved a year (at 12.5 cents KWH). On four way traffic light has 12 bulbs; by switching this will save $900.00 dollars in electricity a year. 150,000 traffic lights throughout the country already have been replaced. They also save more energy if you add in that they do not need to be serviced and replaced as often (shipping of replacement bulbs, trucks driving to the lights to replace the bulbs, etc.). (You also are seeing this lights more and more in tractor trailers on the highways; the savings in this case are not for the energy but that they last longer reducing the amount of maintenance that needs to be done on these trailers.

I saw one estimate that if every light in the country was replaced by LED lights, an amount of energy equivalent to what the USA imports in oil could be saved. Technology is already working on the problem and coming up with economic solutions.

If energy prices stay high, this will hasten this change. LED lights are as bright as regular lights, use 80 to 90 percent less energy and last up to 100,000 hours (over 11 years). I am sure there are many more energy saving technologies on the way!

8)

I agree with the basic thrust of this. The only exception is that I believe some time
in the future the incentives to create new "technologies" (by capitalism and private
investment) will be destroyed.
However, I will concede that energy sources will probably be among the last
victims.

JG
 
JG,

What do you mean by the statement:

The only exception is that I believe some time in the future the incentives to create new "technologies" (by capitalism and private investment) will be destroyed.


I am not sure what you mean by this statement.

Bruce 8)
 
I am pretty sure that John has in mind government's infinite ability to kill the goose that lays the golden egg. Controls and restrictions on business and entrepreneurship have multiplied since the turn of the last century. In our country, at least. I understand that there are one or two former Workers' Paradises that have decided to try somewhat unrestricted capitalism with more success than their previous economic system provided.

Ed
 
Ed_The_Gypsy said:
I am pretty sure that John has in mind government's infinite ability to kill the goose that lays the golden egg.  Controls and restrictions on business and entrepreneurship have multiplied since the turn of the last century.  In our country, at least.  I understand that there are one or two former Workers' Paradises that have decided to try somewhat unrestricted capitalism with more success than their previous economic system provided.

Ed

Pretty good, Ed.

JG
 
Bruce said:
Can anyone answer this question: How much of the price of oil being driven higher by speculation? Do some research; why is the price of finding a barrel of oil in the ground not rising as fast as the price of oil?


8)
I have heard from decent sources that speculation accounts for as much as 20% of trading.
I don't know how the cost of finding compares with a barrel of oil, but for sure the price of finding is going up and fast.  More demand to find oil with a somewhat finite supply of rigs equals higher rig costs.  These guys feast when they can. Simple supply and demand once again.
Yeah, it's all pretty much a scam. :eek:
 
"While I do not disagree with Hubbert and his bell curve of oil production, he does not take into account productivity improvements in extraction of oil; I think if these was put into his bell curve it would skew it to the left:"

For what it's worth: I read on a Yahoo message board that 3-D seismic, where they detonate explosives to map underground oil deposits, improves the ability to find it to 75%. 2-D seismic usually provides enough accuracy to find oil 25% of the time. Most of this work/improvement, between 2-D and 3-D, is done with computers. This is a significant productivty improvement. Drilling 1/3 of the holes you previously had to saves a significant amont of money.

Of course, the bullseyes are smaller and further away now than 20 years ago too.

--Greg
 
Here is another news item about oil:

The United States Geological Service has publically stated that the United States will run out of oil in 9 years. This statement has caused mounting hysteria and has caused the president to act. Great Britain is also very concerned and has acted to secure more oil supplies.

Of course they said this in 1919!

Bruce 8)
 
I am going to start riding my my bike to work. This is not as bad as the 70's when we had to stand inline to get gas.
 
Lets look at oil supplies and Mr. Hubbert

In 1899 the Kern oil field was discovered in California. In 1942 it was estimated that there were 54 million barrels in reserves remaining (after 43 years of pumping oil). In the next 44 years this field produced 736 million barrels and in 1986 it was estimated that 970 million barrels remain. The amount of oil in the ground has not changed; our knowledge has changed as we have learned more about the geology of oil. There are hundreds of oil fields that follow this pattern.

The problem with Hubbert is that his theory is that it is based on a few assumptions:

1) His their assunes that the structure and geology of the planet is well known and fully explored.

2) His theory makes the assumption that all oil well fields will produce at a rate that matches a bell curve.

3) His theory does not take into consideration improving technology in finding oil.

4) His theory does not take into account an increase in price will cause more people to look for oil and vice versa.

I don't think the price of oil is due to its scarcity. There are other factors at work:

1) Speculation (including the fear of a major terrorist attack in Saudia Arabia).

2) Oil companies have been burnt before by ramping up production when the price increases, only to see the prices drop drastically. They are a little gun shy to drill more wells until they know the price will stay high for a longer period of time.

3) The price of oil fell so much in the 1980's that a lot of the companies that drill for oil went out of business and many of the experienced oil workers have retired or moved to other industries. It takes time to build this expertise back up.

The price to find a "new" barrel of oil reserves has been falling since the 1970's because of the widespread use of technology.

I am not sure the energy sector is a good investment over a longer period of time. In my arrogant opinion, the longer the prices stay high the further they will fall when they do go down; I would not be surprised to see a 50% drop in the price of a barrel of oil.

Bruce

8)
 
Do remember that there are two markets for petroleum: the spot market and long-term contracts. The prices we see quoted for oil are spot prices and are the most volatile. Granted, oil is no longer stored the way it used to be. Neither are there tankers waiting just over the horizon. People can't just buy a bunch of oil and hold it; they have to buy and sell contracts for oil, not the oil itself

I don't see any problem with wild LEGAL speculation in oil. If someone wants to bet big on oil, let them. They are just as likely to lose big as win big. There are too many players to be able to corner the market.

Remember Bernstien's lesson: Embrace volatility!

Ed
 
Current futures for light sweet today from nymex-

Sep 2005     61.53    61.59    61.59    61.67    61.34    61.57     -0.04   
Oct 2005     62.61    0.00    0.00    62.75    62.41    62.70     -0.09   
Nov 2005     63.35    0.00    0.00    63.45    63.15    63.43     -0.08   
Dec 2005     63.87    0.00    0.00    64.00    63.67    63.96     -0.09   
Jan 2006     64.24    0.00    0.00    64.33    64.08    64.32     -0.08   
Feb 2006     64.52    0.00    0.00    64.52    64.42    64.54     -0.02

It's not just the spot price that's high, it's also the futures.

The price to find a "new" barrel of oil reserves has been falling since the 1970's because of the widespread use of technology.

Like drilling two miles down into the continental shelf as opposed to a few hundred feet in TX?
 
Ed_The_Gypsy said:
Do remember that there are two markets for petroleum: the spot market and long-term contracts.  The prices we see quoted for oil are spot prices and are the most volatile.  Granted, oil is no longer stored the way it used to be.  Neither are there tankers waiting just over the horizon.  People can't just buy a bunch of oil and hold it; they have to buy and sell contracts for oil, not the oil itself

I don't see any problem with wild LEGAL speculation in oil.  If someone wants to bet big on oil, let them.  They are just as likely to lose big as win big.  There are too many players to be able to corner the market.

Remember Bernstien's lesson: Embrace volatility!

Ed
Not sure what you are saying about the different contracts and how they relate to price, but below is a years worth.  Pick your bargain :eek:

Open High Low Last  
Sep 05 60.51 62.3 60.51
Oct 05 62.1 63.3 61.6 62.6
Nov 05 62.8 64 62.3 63.25  
Dec 05 63.35 64.5 62.81 63.9
Jan 06 63.85 64.6 63.32 64.45
Feb 06 64.2 64.9 63.68 64.4  
Mar 06 64.25 64.95 63.75 64.72
Apr 06 64.1 64.1 63.73 64.1
May 06 64.25 64.3 64.3 64.25
Jul 06 63.7 63.7 63.7 63.7
Aug 06 63.7 64 63.3 64
Sep 06 64 64.25 63.9 64.2
 
FWIW my BIL recently retired from ARAMCO in Saudi Arabia after 20 years service. I recall him saying:

You have no idea how much oil this place has. No one knows. Modern measuring devices don't register high enough to calculate the amount of oil in some of these fields. Additionally, many wells are artesian and dont require much pumping to get the light crude onto the tanker. Its an oversimplification, but it just flows...
 
Yes the futures show that prices will stay high. But futures are just a market guess of future prices; two years ago I am willing to bet the futures did not show $60.00 oil today.

Bruce 8)
 
Back
Top Bottom